Posts

Showing posts from 2020

Book Review: Sunnate Nabavi aur Hamara Tareeqa e Fikr o Amal

Image
Sunnate Nabavi aur Hamara Tareeqa e Fikr o Amal Author: Dr. Yusuf alQarzawi, pages 272. This book seeks to explore the corruption and manipulation of Hadith literature in its various forms and then goes on to suggest ways and means to interpret aHadith to suit contemporary needs; and as expected of the author, it adopts an approach that borders on liberalism. He says that there are three things which have been done to corrupt aHadith: 1. Exaggerations (gulu) 2. False attributions to invent bidaat 3. Incorrect derivations by naïve people And that three things need to be checked while studying any Hadith: 1. Authenticity 2. Context 3. Concurrence with nass He explains that meticulous care should be taken about the authenticity of the Hadith if it involves deriving legal issues from it, and the same care need not be taken with fazail/raqaiq/azkar… but there’s a limit to this.  The learned scholar proceeds to debunk almost all aHadith that deal with fazail and raqaiq. We do know that many

Why are we always a day late?

Image
Some people ask- and they ask this every year- why we Indians celebrate Eid or mark Arafah/Ramazan a day after the Arabs and the West and pretty much the entire world. This question arises because we are used to seeing the world with Japan to the extreme right and the USA to the extreme west of the atlas. But what we need to understand is that this perspective of the globe, and the International Date Line that runs between Alaska and Russia, are both arbitrary. The world is round; so technically, any longitude on the globe can be taken as the International Date Line. When it is 1st Jan in Japan, it is still 31st Dec in Alaska, and it remains so for almost 24 hours. This, despite the fact that they share the same night. The International Date Line of Islam, however, is not arbitrary. It begins at the place where the moon is first sighted. And that place is towards Western Pakistan/Iran. So naturally, the date also begins there. The 1st of Ramazan, for example, begins at Isla